Virtual switch QoS mode during migrations

Introduction

In Shared nothing live migration with a virtual switch change and VLAN ID configuration I published a sample script. The script works well. But there are two areas of improvement. The first one is here in Checkpoint references a non-existent virtual switch. This post is about the second one. Here I show that I also need to check the virtual switch QoS mode during migrations. A couple of the virtual machines on the source nodes had absolute minimum and/or maximum bandwidth set. On the target nodes, all the virtual switches are created by PowerShell. This defaults to weight mode for QoS, which is the more sensible option, albeit not always the easiest or practical one for people to use.

Virtual switch QoS mode during migrations

First a quick recap of what we are doing. The challenge was to shared nothing live migrate virtual machines to a host with different virtual switch names and VLAN IDs. We did so by adding dummy virtual switches to the target host. This made share nothing live migration possible. On arrival of the virtual machine on the target host, we immediately connect the virtual network adapters to the final virtual switch and set the correct VLAN IDs. That works very well. You drop 1 or at most 2 pings, this is as good as it gets.

This goes wrong under the following conditions:

  • The source virtual switch has QoS mode absolute.
  • Virtual network adapter connected to the source virtual switch has MinimumBandwidthAbsolute and/or MaximumBandwidth set.
  • The target virtual switch with QoS mode weighted

This will cause connectivity loss as you cannot set absolute values to a virtual network attached to a weighted virtual switch. So connecting the virtual to the new virtual switch just fails and you lose connectivity. Remember that the virtual machine is connected to a dummy virtual switch just to make the live migration work and we need to swap it over immediately. The VLAN ID does get set correctly actually. Let’s deal with this.

Steps to fix this issue

First of all, we adapt the script to check the QoS mode on the source virtual switches. If it is set to absolute we know we need to check for any settings of MinimumBandwidthAbsolute and MaximumBandwidth on the virtual adapters connected to those virtual switches. These changes are highlighted in the demo code below.

Secondly, we adapt the script to check every virtual network adapter for its bandwidth management settings. If we find configured MinimumBandwidthAbsolute and MaximumBandwidth values we set these to 0 and as such disable the bandwidth settings. This makes sure that connecting the virtual network adapters to the new virtual switch with QoS mode weighted will succeed. These changes are highlighted in the demo code below.

Finally, the complete script

#The source Hyper-V host
$SourceNode = 'NODE-A'
#The LUN where you want to storage migrate your VMs away from
$SourceRootPath = "C:\ClusterStorage\Volume1*"
#The source Hyper-V host

#The target Hypr-V host
$TargetNode = 'ZULU'
#The storage pathe where you want to storage migrate your VMs to
$TargetRootPath = "C:\ClusterStorage\Volume1"

$OldVirtualSwitch01 = 'vSwitch-VLAN500'
$OldVirtualSwitch02 = 'vSwitch-VLAN600'
$NewVirtualSwitch = 'ConvergedVirtualSwitch'
$VlanId01 = 500
$VlanId02 = 600
  
if ((Get-VMSwitch -name $OldVirtualSwitch01 ).BandwidthReservationMode -eq 'Absolute') { 
    $OldVirtualSwitch01QoSMode = 'Absolute'
}
if ((Get-VMSwitch -name $OldVirtualSwitch01 ).BandwidthReservationMode -eq 'Absolute') { 
    $OldVirtualSwitch02QoSMode = 'Absolute'
}
    
#Grab all the VM we find that have virtual disks on the source CSV - WARNING for W2K12 you'll need to loop through all cluster nodes.
$AllVMsOnRootPath = Get-VM -ComputerName $SourceNode | where-object { $_.HardDrives.Path -like $SourceRootPath }

#We loop through all VMs we find on our SourceRoootPath
ForEach ($VM in $AllVMsOnRootPath) {
    #We generate the final VM destination path
    $TargetVMPath = $TargetRootPath + "\" + ($VM.Name).ToUpper()
    #Grab the VM name
    $VMName = $VM.Name
    $VM.VMid
    $VMName

    #If the VM is still clusterd, get it removed form the cluster as live shared nothing migration will otherwise fail.
    if ($VM.isclustered -eq $True) {
        write-Host -ForegroundColor Magenta $VM.Name "is clustered and is being removed from cluster"
        Remove-ClusterGroup -VMId $VM.VMid -Force -RemoveResources
        Do { Start-Sleep -seconds 1 } While ($VM.isclustered -eq $True)
        write-Host -ForegroundColor Yellow $VM.Name "has been removed from cluster"
    }
    #If the VM checkpoint, notify the user of the script as this will cause issues after swicthing to the new virtual
    #switch on the target node. Live migration will fail between cluster nodes if the checkpoints references 1 or more
    #non existing virtual switches. These must be removed prior to of after completing the shared nothing migration.
    #The script does this after the migration automatically, not before as I want it to be untouched if the shared nothing
    #migration fails.

    $checkpoints = get-vmcheckpoint -VMName $VM.Name

    if ($Null -ne $checkpoints) {
        write-host -foregroundcolor yellow "This VM has checkpoints"
        write-host -foregroundcolor yellow "This VM will be migrated to the new host"
        write-host -foregroundcolor yellow "Only after a succesfull migration will ALL the checpoints be removed"
    }
    
    #Do the actual storage migration of the VM, $DestinationVMPath creates the default subfolder structure
    #for the virtual machine config, snapshots, smartpaging & virtual hard disk files.
    Move-VM -Name $VMName -ComputerName $VM.ComputerName -IncludeStorage -DestinationStoragePath $TargetVMPath -DestinationHost $TargetNode
    
    $MovedVM = Get-VM -ComputerName $TargetNode -Name $VMName

    $vNICOnOldvSwitch01 = Get-VMNetworkAdapter -ComputerName $TargetNode -VMName $MovedVM.VMName | where-object SwitchName -eq $OldVirtualSwitch01
    if ($Null -ne $vNICOnOldvSwitch01) {
        foreach ($VMNetworkadapater in $vNICOnOldvSwitch01) {   
            if ($OldVirtualSwitch01QoSMode -eq 'Absolute') { 
                if (0 -ne $VMNetworkAdapter.bandwidthsetting.Maximumbandwidth) {
                    write-host -foregroundcolor cyan "Network adapter $VMNetworkAdapter.Name of VM $VMName MaximumBandwidth will be reset to 0."
                    Set-VMNetworkAdapter -Name $VMNetworkAdapter.Name -VMName $MovedVM.Name -ComputerName $TargetNode -MaximumBandwidth 0
                }
                if (0 -ne $VMNetworkAdapter.bandwidthsetting.MinimumBandwidthAbsolute) {
                    write-host -foregroundcolor cyan "Network adapter $VMNetworkAdapter.Name of VM $VMName MaximuBandwidthAbsolute will be reset to 0."
                    Set-VMNetworkAdapter -Name $VMNetworkAdapter.Name -VMName $MovedVM.Name -ComputerName $TargetNode -MinimumBandwidthAbsolute 0
                }
            }
                
            write-host 'Moving to correct vSwitch'
            Connect-VMNetworkAdapter -VMNetworkAdapter $vNICOnOldvSwitch01 -SwitchName $NewVirtualSwitch
            write-host "Setting VLAN $VlanId01"
            Set-VMNetworkAdapterVlan  -VMNetworkAdapter $vNICOnOldvSwitch01 -Access -VLANid $VlanId01
        }
    }

    $vNICsOnOldvSwitch02 = Get-VMNetworkAdapter -ComputerName $TargetNode -VMName $MovedVM.VMName | where-object SwitchName -eq $OldVirtualSwitch02
    if ($NULL -ne $vNICsOnOldvSwitch02) {
        foreach ($VMNetworkadapater in $vNICsOnOldvSwitch02) {
            if ($OldVirtualSwitch02QoSMode -eq 'Absolute') { 
                if ($Null -ne $VMNetworkAdapter.bandwidthsetting.Maximumbandwidth) {
                    write-host -foregroundcolor cyan "Network adapter $VMNetworkAdapter.Name of VM $VMName MaximumBandwidth will be reset to 0."
                    Set-VMNetworkAdapter -Name $VMNetworkAdapter.Name -VMName $MovedVM.Name -ComputerName $TargetNode -MaximumBandwidth 0
                }
                if ($Null -ne $VMNetworkAdapter.bandwidthsetting.MinimumBandwidthAbsolute) {
                    write-host -foregroundcolor cyan "Network adapter $VMNetworkAdapter.Name of VM $VMName MaximumBandwidth will be reset to 0."
                    Set-VMNetworkAdapter -Name $VMNetworkAdapter.Name -VMName $MovedVM.Name -ComputerName $TargetNode -MinimumBandwidthAbsolute 0
                }
            }
            write-host 'Moving to correct vSwitch'
            Connect-VMNetworkAdapter -VMNetworkAdapter $vNICsOnOldvSwitch02 -SwitchName $NewVirtualSwitch
            write-host "Setting VLAN $VlanId02"
            Set-VMNetworkAdapterVlan  -VMNetworkAdapter $vNICsOnOldvSwitch02 -Access -VLANid $VlanId02
        }
    }

    #If the VM has checkpoints, this is when we remove them.
    $checkpoints = get-vmcheckpoint -ComputerName $TargetNode -VMName $MovedVM.VMName

    if ($Null -ne $checkpoints) {
        write-host -foregroundcolor yellow "This VM has checkpoints and they will ALL be removed"
        $CheckPoints | Remove-VMCheckpoint 
    }
}

Below is the output of a VM where we had to change the switch name, enable a VLAN ID, deal with absolute QoS settings and remove checkpoints. All this without causing downtime. Nor did we change the original virtual machine in case the shared nothing migration fails.

Some observations

The fact that we are using PowerShell is great. You can only set weighted bandwidth limits via PowerShell. The GUI is only for absolute values and it will throw an error trying to use it when the virtual switch is configured as weighted.

This means you can embed setting the weights in your script if you so desire. If you do, read up on how to handle this best. trying to juggle the weight settings to be 100 in a dynamic environment is a bit of a challenge. So use the default flow pool and keep the number of virtual network adapters with unique settings to a minimum.

Conclusion

To avoid downtime we removed all the set minimum and maximum bandwidth settings on any virtual network adapter. By doing so we ensured that the swap to the new virtual switch right after the successful shared nothing live migration will succeed. If you want you can set weights on the virtual network adapters afterward. But as the bandwidth on these new hosts is now a redundant 25 Gbps, the need was no longer there. As a result, we just left them without. this can always be configured later if it turns out to be needed.

Warning: this is a demo script. It lacks error handling and logging. It can also contain mistakes. But hey you get it for free to adapt and use. Test and adapt this in a lab. You are responsible for what you do in your environments. Running scripts downloaded from the internet without any validation make you a certified nut case. That is not my wrongdoing.

I hope this helps some of you. thanks for reading.

Shared nothing live migration with a virtual switch change and VLAN ID configuration

Introduction

I was working on a hardware refresh, consolidation and upgrade to Windows Server 2019 project. This mainly boils down to cluster operating system rolling upgrades from Windows Server 2016 to Windows Server 2019 with new servers replacing the old ones. Pretty straight forward. So what does this has to do with shared nothing live migration with a virtual switch change and VLAN ID configuration

Due to the consolidation aspect, we also had to move virtual machines from some older clusters to the new clusters. The old cluster nodes have multiple virtual switches. These connect to different VLANs. Some of the virtual machines have on only one virtual network adapter that connects to one of the virtual switches. Many of the virtual machines are multihomed. The number of virtual NICs per virtual machine was anything between 1 to 3. For this purpose, we had the challenge of doing a shared nothing live migration with a virtual switch change and VLAN ID configuration. All this without downtime.

Meeting the challenge

In the new cluster, there is only one converged virtual switch. This virtual switch attaches to trunked network ports with all the required VLANs. As we have only one virtual switch on the new Hyper-V cluster nodes, the name differs from those on the old Hyper-V cluster nodes. This prevents live migration. Fixing this is our challenge.

First of all, compare-vm is your friend to find out blocking incompatibilities between the source and the target nodes. You can read about that in many places. Here, we focus on our challenge.

Making Shared nothing migration work

The first step is to make sure shared nothing migration works. We can achieve this in several ways.

Option 1

We can disconnect the virtual machine network adapters from their virtual switch. While this allows you to migrate the virtual machines, this leads to connectivity loss. This is not acceptable.

Option2

We can preemptively set the virtual machine network adapters to a virtual switch with the same name as the one on the target and enable VLAN ID. Consequently, this means you have to create those and need NICs to do so. but unless you configure and connect those to the network just like on the new Hyper-V hosts this also leads to connectivity loss. That was not possible in this case. So this option again is unacceptable.

Option 3

What I did was create dummy virtual switches on the target hosts. For this purpose, I used some spare LOM NICs. I did not configure them otherwise. As a matter of fact, tI did not even connect them. Just the fact that they exist with the same names as on the old Hyper-V hosts is sufficient to make shared nothing migration possible. Actually, this is a great time point to remind ourselves that we don’t even spare NICs. Dummy private virtual switches that are not even attached to a NIC will also do.

After we have finished the migrations we just delete the dummy virtual switches. That all there is to do if you used private ones. If you used spare NICs just disable them again. Now all is as was and should be on the new cluster nodes.

Turning shared nothing migration into shared nothing live migration

Remember, we need zero downtime. You have to keep in mind that long as the shared nothing live migration is running all is well. We have connectivity to the original virtual machines on the old cluster nodes. As soon as the shared nothing live migration finishes we do 2 things. First of all, we connect the virtual network adapters of the virtual machines to the new converged virtual switch. Also, we enable the VLAN ID. To achieve this, we script it out in PowerShell. As a result, is so fast we only drop only 1 or 2 pings. Just like a standard live migration.

Below you can find a conceptual script you can adapt for your own purposes. For real migrations add logging and error handling. Please note that to leverage share nothing migration you need to be aware of the security requirements. Credential Security Support Provider (CredSSP) is the default option. If you want or must use Kerberos you must configure constrained delegation in Active Directory.

I chose to use CredSSP as we would decommission the old host soon afterward anyway. It also means we did not need Active Directory work done. This can be handy if that is not evident in the environment you are in. We started the script on every source Hyper-V host, migrating a bunch of VMs to a new Hyper-V host. This works very well for us. Hope this helps.

Sample Script

    #The source Hyper-V host
    $SourceNode = 'NODE-A'
    #The LUN where you want to storage migrate your VMs away from
    $SourceRootPath = "C:\ClusterStorage\Volume1*"
    #The source Hyper-V host

    #The target Hypr-V host
    $TargetNode = 'ZULU'
    #The storage pathe where you want to storage migrate your VMs to
    $TargetRootPath = "C:\ClusterStorage\Volume1"

    $OldVirtualSwitch01 = 'vSwitch-VLAN500'
    $OldVirtualSwitch02 = 'vSwitch-VLAN600'
    $NewVirtualSwitch = 'ConvergedVirtualSwitch'
    $VlanId01 = 500
    $VlanId02 = 600

    #Grab all the VM we find that have virtual disks on the source CSV - WARNING for W2K12 you'll need to loop through all cluster nodes.
    $AllVMsOnRootPath = Get-VM -ComputerName $SourceNode | where-object { $_.HardDrives.Path -like $SourceRootPath }

    #We loop through all VMs we find on our SourceRoootPath
    ForEach ($VM in $AllVMsOnRootPath) {
        #We generate the final VM destination path
        $TargetVMPath = $TargetRootPath + "\" + ($VM.Name).ToUpper()
        #Grab the VM name
        $VMName = $VM.Name
        $VM.VMid
        $VMName


        if ($VM.isclustered -eq $True) {
            write-Host -ForegroundColor Magenta $VM.Name "is clustered and is being removed from cluster"
            Remove-ClusterGroup -VMId $VM.VMid -Force -RemoveResources
            Do { Start-Sleep -seconds 1 } While ($VM.isclustered -eq $True)
            write-Host -ForegroundColor Yellow $VM.Name "has been removed from cluster"
        }
    
        #Do the actual storage migration of the VM, $DestinationVMPath creates the default subfolder structure
        #for the virtual machine config, snapshots, smartpaging & virtual hard disk files.
        Move-VM -Name $VMName -ComputerName $VM.ComputerName -IncludeStorage -DestinationStoragePath $TargetVMPath -DestinationHost $TargetNode
    
         $OldvSwitch01 = Get-VMNetworkAdapter -ComputerName $TargetNode -VMName $MovedVM.VMName | where-object SwitchName -eq $OldVirtualSwitch01

        if ($Null -ne $OldvSwitch01) {
            foreach ($VMNetworkadapater in $OldvSwitch01)
            {   write-host 'Moving to correct vSwitch'
                Connect-VMNetworkAdapter -VMNetworkAdapter $OldvSwitch01 -SwitchName $NewVirtualSwitch
                write-out "Setting VLAN $VlanId01"
                Set-VMNetworkAdapterVlan  -VMNetworkAdapter $OldvSwitch01 -Access -VLANid $VlanId01
            }
        }
        $OldvSwitch02 = Get-VMNetworkAdapter -ComputerName $TargetNode -VMName $MovedVM.VMName | where-object SwitchName -eq $OldVirtualSwitch02
        if ($NULL -ne $OldvSwitch02) {
            foreach ($VMNetworkadapater in $OldvSwitch02) {
                write-host 'Moving to correct vSwitch'
                Connect-VMNetworkAdapter -VMNetworkAdapter $OldvSwitch02 -SwitchName $NewVirtualSwitch
                write-host "Setting VLAN $VlanId02"
                Set-VMNetworkAdapterVlan  -VMNetworkAdapter $OldvSwitch02 -Access -VLANid $VlanId02
            }
        }
    }



Add HBAs to SC Series Servers with Add-DellScPhysicalServerHba

Introduction

Before I dump the script to add HBAs to SC Series Servers with Add-DellScPhysicalServerHba on you, first some context. I have been quite busy with multiple SAN migrations. A bunch of older DELLEMC SC Series (Compellent) to newer All Flash Arrays (see My first Dell SC7020(F) Array Solution)  When I find the time I’ll share some more PowerShell snippets I use to make such efforts a bit easier. It’s quite addictive and it allows you migrate effectively and efficiently.

In the SC Series we create cluster objects in which we place server objects. That make life easier on the SAN end.image

Those server objects are connected to the SAN via FC or iSCSI. For this we need to add the HBAs to the servers after we have set up the zoning correctly. That’s a whole different subject.

image

This is tedious work in the user interface, especially when there are many WWN entries visible that need to be assigned. Mistakes can happen. This is where automation comes in handy and a real time saver when you have many clusters/nodes and multiple SANs. So well show you how to grab the WWN info your need from the cluster nodes to add HBAs to SC Series Servers with Add-DellScPhysicalServerHba.

Below you see a script that loops through all the nodes of a cluster and gets the HBA WWNs we need. I than adds those WWNs to the SC Series server object. In another blog post I’ll share so snippets to gather the cluster info needed to create the cluster objects and server objects on the Compellent SC Series SAN. In this blog post we’ll assume the server have objects has been created.

We leverage the Dell Storage Manager – 2016 R3.20 Release (Public PowerShell SDK for Dell Storage API). I hope it helps.

Add HBAs to SC Series Servers with Add-DellScPhysicalServerHba

function Get-WinOSHBAInfo
#Basically add 3 nicely formated properties to the HBA info we get via WMI
#These are the NodeWWW, the PortWWN and the FabricName. The raw attributes
#from WMI are not readily consumable. WWNs are given with a ":" delimiter.
#This can easiliy be replaced or removed depending on the need. 
{ 
param ($ComputerName = "localhost")
 
# Get HBA Information
$Port = Get-WmiObject -ComputerName $ComputerName -Class MSFC_FibrePortHBAAttributes -Namespace "root\WMI"
$HBAs = Get-WmiObject -ComputerName $ComputerName -Class MSFC_FCAdapterHBAAttributes  -Namespace "root\WMI"
 
$HBAProperties = $HBAs | Get-Member -MemberType Property, AliasProperty | Select -ExpandProperty name | ? {$_ -notlike "__*"}
$HBAs = $HBAs | Select-Object $HBAProperties
$HBAs | % { $_.NodeWWN = ((($_.NodeWWN) | % {"{0:x2}" -f $_}) -join ":").ToUpper() }
 
ForEach ($HBA in $HBAs) {
 
    # Get Port WWN
    $PortWWN = (($Port |? { $_.instancename -eq $HBA.instancename }).attributes).PortWWN
    $PortWWN = (($PortWWN | % {"{0:x2}" -f $_}) -join ":").ToUpper()
    Add-Member -MemberType NoteProperty -InputObject $HBA -Name PortWWN -Value $PortWWN
    # Get Fabric WWN
    $FabricWWN = (($Port |? { $_.instancename -eq $HBA.instancename }).attributes).FabricName
    $FabricWWN = (($FabricWWN | % {"{0:x2}" -f $_}) -join ":").ToUpper()
    Add-Member -MemberType NoteProperty -InputObject $HBA -Name FabricWWN -Value $FabricWWN
 
    # Output
    $HBA
}
}
#Grab the cluster nane in a variable. Adapt thiscode to loop through all your clusters.
$ClusterName = "DEMOLABCLUSTER"
#Grab all cluster node 
$ClusterNodes = Get-Cluster -name $ClusterName | Get-ClusterNode

#Create array of custom object to store ClusterName, the cluster nodes and the HBAs
$ServerWWNArray = @()

ForEach ($ClusterNode in $ClusterNodes) {
    #We loop through the cluster nodes the cluster and for each one we grab the HBAs that are relevant.
    #My lab nodes have different types installed up and off, so I specify the manufacturer to get the relevant ones.
    #Adapt to your needs. You ca also use modeldescription to filter out FCoE vers FC HBAs etc.
    $AllHBAPorts = Get-WinOSHBAInfo -ComputerName $ClusterNode.Name | Where-Object {$_.Manufacturer -eq "Emulex Corporation"} 

    #The SC Series SAN PowerShell takes the WWNs without any delimiters, so we dump the ":" for this use case.
    $WWNs = $AllHBAPorts.PortWWN -replace ":", ""
    $NodeName = $ClusterNode.Name

    #Build a nice node object with the info and add it to the $ServerWWNArray 
    $ServerWWNObject = New-Object psobject -Property @{
        WWN         = $WWNs
        ServerName  = $NodeName 
        ClusterName = $ClusterName         
    }
    $ServerWWNArray += $ServerWWNObject
}

#Show our array
($ServerWWNArray).WWN

#just a demo to list what's in the array
ForEach ($ServerNode in $ServerWWNArray) {
    
    $Servernode.ServerName
    $Servernode.WWN
}

#Now add the HBA to the servers in the cluster.
#This is part of a bigger script that gathers all HBA/WWN infor for all clusters
#and creates the Compellent SC Series Cluster Object, the Servers, add the HBA's
#I'll post more snippets in futire blog post to show how to do that and give you
#some ideas for your own environment.

import-module "C:\SysAdmin\Tools\DellStoragePowerShellSDK\DellStorage.ApiCommandSet.dll"

#region SetUpDSMAccess Variable & credentials
Get-DellScController
$DsmHostName = "MyDSMHost.domain.local"
$DsmUserName = "MyUserName"
# Prompt for the password
$DsmPassword = Read-Host -AsSecureString -Prompt "Please enter the password for $DsmUserName"

# Create the connection
Connect-DellApiConnection -HostName $DsmHostName -User $DsmUserName -Password $DsmPassword -Save MyConnection 

#Assign variables
$ConnName = "MyConnection "
$ScName = "MySCName"

# Get the Storage Center
$StorageCenter = Get-DellStorageCenter -ConnectionName $ConnName -Name $ScName


ForEach ( $ClusterNodeWWNInfo in  $ServerWWNArray ) {
    # Get the server
    $Server = Get-DellScPhysicalServer -StorageCenter $StorageCenter -Name $ClusterNodeWWNInfo.ServerName
    $PortType = [DellStorage.Api.Enums.FrontEndTransportTypeEnum] "FibreChannel"
  
    ForEach ($WWN in $ClusterNodeWWNInfo.WWN)
    {
     # Add the array of WWNs for the cluster node and add them to the SC Compellent server
      Add-DellScPhysicalServerHba -ConnectionName $ConnName `
     -Instance $Server `
     -HbaPortType $PortType `
     -WwnOrIscsiName $WWN  -Confirm:$false
     }
}